Cookie-Mailing Month and Giveaway!
I have a sad story to tell. Last year, my brother (serving in South America) requested a box of our family’s homemade Christmas toffee. I lovingly collected the ingredients, and found an adorable cookie tin for packaging. With Christmas music blaring over the stereo speakers, I melted down chocolate in my double boiler, chopped walnuts and poured molten caramel. Just look at the result:
The day before I was going to write a blog post about it, my brother emailed me, saying he’d received the tin of toffee. Here is a picture of how it arrived:
In my brother’s own words: “megan’s toffee, huddled, hiding in the corner of the tin”
Needless to say, the toffee didn’t make the blog (although my brother ate it anyway). Since then, I’ve brooded over which is the best method for sending homemade treats. Do certain baked goods hold up better than others? Is there a type of packaging that is best for protecting the goodies over which we’ve slaved? What do they really look like when they arrive?
In this spirit, I’m declaring October “Cookie-Mailing Month” here at Missionary Ideas. In addition to regular Halloween-themed posts, I’ll be testing recipes, as well as packing & shipping methods. Hopefully, I can get to the bottom of this.
It is also my pleasure to announce this blog’s very first giveaway. Going along with our cookie-mailing theme, one winner will receive a Reynolds 00590 Handi-Vac Vacuum-Sealing Starter Kit, which I will be testing this month as well. Just in time for packaging and sending Christmas cookies to your missionary!
To enter the drawing, you have several options: 1. Get my new button for your blog, 2. Make a comment with a question or suggestion about sending homemade treats, or 3. Announce this giveaway (and include the link) in your Facebook or Twitter status. Each contestant can get up to three entries; just let me know how you’ve entered in your comment below!
Let the Month of Cookie-Mailing begin!

7 Comments
Sadie Wheeler
03 Oct 2011 12:10 pm
I am really interested it what you end up finding. My missionary is in Thailand and I would love to send him cookies or normal food.
loa337
04 Oct 2011 12:10 am
Keep up posted on what you find that works! I need to send chocolate chip cookies pretty soon to our missionary.
Liz M.
05 Oct 2011 12:10 am
I too would like tips on sending chocolate chip cookies! I found an online resource with suggestions for mailing cookies, and it said that chewy cookies ship well but shouldn’t be in the mail for over a week (http://allrecipes.com/HowTo/mailing-cookies/detail.aspx) and not to mix chewy with crispy cookies. I haven’t experimented myself so I’m not sure how true this is…
Liz M.
05 Oct 2011 12:10 am
I shared this post on FB!
Holly F.
06 Oct 2011 10:10 am
I’ll admit, I don’t have a lot of experience sending homemade treats in the mail. But, if I were a betting man, I would bet that I would be too scared to send anything chocolate—too many chances to get melty. Maybe a vacuum sealer would make me less scared.
Sadie Wheeler
22 Oct 2011 10:10 pm
I got your button on my blog!
Cookie Month Results and Giveaway Winner! | Missionary Ideas
17 Dec 2011 11:12 am
[...] the results are finally in! With the help of my sister at BYU Idaho, our cookie study is complete. (I was going to send the cookies to my brother in Honduras, but he got home from his [...]
Leave a Comment